Aunty Betty's House: November 2011
In this piece of writing I want to explore the indexical nature of the family snap in relation to the physical artefact. As stated in previous text the use of photography is “the most widely used medium in the visual arts that embodies an indexical relationship to its subject.”[1] Furthering this is the question why do we collect imagery of the past and how does this relate to the recollection of events. The “snapshot aesthetic”[2], no matter how out of focus or unclear are “heavily impregnated with memory…and lived experience”[3]. When discussing the sculpture, Untitled (Yellow Bed, Two Parts) (1991) works by Rachel Whiteread, whose cast, Gibbons suggest “hold traces of the object’s ‘life’ until being frozen in time”,[4] the casts hold imprints of past times “in dental plaster, a finely ground plaster that picks up on minute detail with accuracy”,[5] they can suggest what might have been from “the creases in the mattress but absorbs some of the staining that had occurred on it, again revealing forensic-like traces of its past life”[6]. However a photograph is more literal. “Firstly, the medium – that of photography – although again indexical, generates a trace of a different order from the imprint left by the cast”[7] leading back to the initial quote by Gibbons.
The practical work produced as part of this research is shot in reaction to personal memory, family snaps and “the work of Nan Goldin and Miyako Ishiuchi which has a strong autobiographical lean”[8] illustrating traces of “lived experience… much redolent with somatic memories as with emotional associations”.[9] In the case of Goldin’s work “a number of (Goldin’s) friends and peer group have subsequently died, giving the posthumous status of memento mori to works that were initially conceived as memoirs.”[10] The stance of the practical work produced to date for this research is about an early stage in my life when my senses were not developed enough to absorb information leading to memories and as Gibbons suggests when discussing Goldin’s work “to one extent or another, connected to themes of death, loss and absence”,[11] this in relation to the work produced in the practical aspect of the research the imagery is discussing a period that cannot be recreated, but is looking to not necessarily recapture that time or to answer questions but to investigate how photographs prompt memory recollection through presenting work “only in the form of traces – not icons, not symbols, but indices”[12] within the personal set of images covering the first seven years of my life.
In quoting Annette Kuhn, Gibbons suggests that her work “has shown in her account of her own family photographs, family photographs are never just records of the moment, whether anecdotal or formal or anywhere in between. They form part of larger interpersonal, sociological and ideological networks and are always historically and culturally specific.”[13]
The photographic body of work that is produced within the practical research may not be as shocking or controversial as Goldin’s work but will allow the viewer to “capture and hold the particular ambience of places of special cultural or historical significance”[14] using contemporary apparatus and techniques to capture the observers conscious.
The crux of the research is to explore “the relationship between the representation and the represented”,[15] to delve into the” formative experiences”[16] and “emotional associations”[17] of the family photograph. While memory at an early age is often hard to recall, the photograph, while it may not show fact does lay of trace of representation; “the thing that has been there”[18] as “photographs are characterised by a physical connection to the thing photographed.”[19] Quoting Peirce, Gibbons states “that it is ‘in dynamical connection both with the individual object, on the one hand, and with the senses of memory of the person for whom it serves as a sign, on the other’.”[20] Photographs collected as a starting point are as Gibbons quoting Victor Burgin “argued, the viewer comes to the photograph with pretextual knowledge; for instance, conventions of representation can be and are borrowed from other arenas of visual practice, such as painting, in addition to which the viewer brings foreknowledge of the cultural meaning attached to the things represented.”[21] Furthering Burgin’s quote Gibbons suggest that “the naturalness of the photographic image is a deceit. Objects present to the camera are already in use in the production of meanings and photography has no choice but to operate on such meanings”[22]
The crux of the research is to explore “the relationship between the representation and the represented”,[15] to delve into the” formative experiences”[16] and “emotional associations”[17] of the family photograph. While memory at an early age is often hard to recall, the photograph, while it may not show fact does lay of trace of representation; “the thing that has been there”[18] as “photographs are characterised by a physical connection to the thing photographed.”[19] Quoting Peirce, Gibbons states “that it is ‘in dynamical connection both with the individual object, on the one hand, and with the senses of memory of the person for whom it serves as a sign, on the other’.”[20] Photographs collected as a starting point are as Gibbons quoting Victor Burgin “argued, the viewer comes to the photograph with pretextual knowledge; for instance, conventions of representation can be and are borrowed from other arenas of visual practice, such as painting, in addition to which the viewer brings foreknowledge of the cultural meaning attached to the things represented.”[21] Furthering Burgin’s quote Gibbons suggest that “the naturalness of the photographic image is a deceit. Objects present to the camera are already in use in the production of meanings and photography has no choice but to operate on such meanings”[22]
Roland Barthes upon finding the photograph of his mother as “not an image of his mother as she looked, but one which spoke of her in essence, found eventually in a single photograph of her as a child in a winter garden (which he declined to reproduce)”[23], unpacking this statement it is clear that a photograph is the freezing of time and the surreal property it holds “astonishing and metaphysical”[24] and as William Henry Fox Talbot described his discovery in 1939 as “marvellous”[25] and a “‘natural magic’”[26] “The photographic process involves a ghostly transference of the real (the loss of corporeality) in which objects are dematerialised”[27]
“While Barthes seeks out his mother through a meditation on photography, Ishiuchi uses photography as a medium of remembrance.”[28] Ishiuchi epitomises her mothers “’humanness’”[29] though the photograph as “intimate reminders”[30] “posterity and commemoration”[31] “weight of emotion” in relation to the work that utilises her mothers possessions. “She inflects the medium in a way that fetisheses her subject matter, recalling older types of remembrance photography”.[32] While in Goldin’s work: “Her ‘style’ is predominantly that of the snapshot, although, as has been noted elsewhere, her work is also filmic in the way that the images are ‘like “frames” (in the cinematic sense) belonging to a more complex narrative.”[33] “A framework of recording and remembrance is set up in which Goldin readily speaks of the way that her suites of images equate to the process of memory.”[34]
On reflection of the text: “The photographic traces in the work of Ishiuchi and Goldin are both intimate and personalised.”[35] Gibbons concludes that “as Annette Kuhn has shown in her account of her own family photographs, family photographs are never just records of the moment, whether anecdotal or formal or anywhere in between. They form part of a larger interpersonal, sociological and ideological networks and are always historically and culturally specific.”[36] In the photographs produced in my work it is possible that the viewer maybe able to identify with the event, as with the photographs by Nan Goldin; or the change of appearance or physical perception of the work by Miyako Ishiuchi.
[1] Gibbons, J.
[2] Gibbons, J.
[3] Gibbons, J.
[4] Gibbons, J.
[5] Gibbons, J.
[6] Gibbons, J.
[7] Gibbons, J.
[8] Gibbons, J.
[9] Gibbons, J.
[10] Gibbons, J.
[11] Gibbons, J.
[12] Gibbons, J.
[13] Gibbons, J.
[14] Gibbons, J.
[15] Gibbons, J.
[16] Gibbons, J.
[17] Gibbons, J.
[18] Gibbons, J.
[19] Gibbons, J.
[20] Gibbons, J.
[21] Gibbons, J.
[22] Gibbons, J.
[23] Gibbons, J.
[24] Gibbons, J.
[25] Gibbons, J.
[26] Gibbons, J.
[27] Gibbons, J.
[28] Gibbons, J.
[29] Gibbons, J.
[30] Gibbons, J.
[31] Gibbons, J.
[32] Gibbons, J.
[33] Gibbons, J.
[34] Gibbons, J.
[35] Gibbons, J.
[36] Gibbons, J.


No comments:
Post a Comment