The family album takes many different forms, some are formal, with bound volumes of collections of images or a digital equivalent, and others take the form of boxes of endless, unsorted photographs. In my experience the family album has been the latter, as a family we have not exhibited photographs of ourselves, with the exception of the obligatory school Tempest Photograph, often choosing instead to show a vista or intrinsic items that unlock signifiers to the past. In her book On Photography Susan Sontag stated: “They are a grammar and, even more importantly, an ethics of seeing. Finally, the most grandiose result of the photographic enterprise is to give us the sense that we can hold the world in our heads – as an anthology of images.”
This way of holding memories possibly goes some way to explaining the lack of photographs – this is a subject that I will cover later in this text. While the objects and vistas describe events and allow memory to be triggered they are in reality an opening into the realms of fantasy. While a photograph a single still moment in time, it allows the viewer to experience the event with reference to the dress, landscape, texture and nostalgia of the time it was taken. In turn this creates a reaction, building an emotion surrounding the image and event. In essence all photographs allude to creating evidence as a record no matter of the subject whether of the subject matter; or as Barthes furthers the rhetoric of the photographic image, by stating: “A specific photograph, in effect, is never distinguished from its referent (from what it represents).”
A mode of testing memory undertaken is to ask questions within an interview, the method used for this was to record participants memory – along with this I also asked them to send postcards. The brief was to visit an area and seek out locations from memory and how they have changed. In some examples places have not changed, but in others cases the change is drastic. An example of this was the case of Southport. The original site of a paddling pool has been replaced by a business park – in essence this is a chain hotel and restaurants, but at least this is still a leisure activity location.
 |
| Southport 1978 |
 |
| Southport 2011 |
The postcards (in this example Filey) have worked well and this has led to further conversations and interviews which have been interesting as both sides of the conversation strive to remember and expand on the topics discussed. In the case of the postcard sent by my parents, they mentioned that they searched for the Salvation Army Building. This is something that I have no recollection, but is something that I intend to pursue with my brother later. My main memory is falling into the paddling pool and watching Buck Rogers in black and white on television. Apparently both myself and my brother were fuming that we had been left for the day – in essence this was, according to my mum and hour and a half at the most.
The strongest memory I have of Filey was that it was always hot, in contrast Blackpool was always raining. Other memories we shared was the lifeboat house and Corrigans Fun Centre (slot machines). Again Corrigans was always about arcade-games and Blackpool was the two penny shoves – and still is. The lights attract me like a shiny object to a magpie. The amusement arcade combined with the joke-shop, ice-cream parlour and the sun and see still have a warm cosy appeal.
 |
| Postcard of original memory (by Matthew Smith) |
 |
| Postcard of found evidence (by Matthew Smith) |
 |
| Postcard of original memory (by Mum and Dad - written by Mum) |
The intrinsic value of a photograph is that the image is always in the past, where as a moving image is in the present. With a moving film the narrative is paramount to the device; you are observing an event that is taking place, where as with a photograph the event has taken place: “that-has-been.” In his book Camera Lucida, Roland Barthes discusses the photograph as always being in the past talking about an image of his mother in the garden of her house. The garden remains the same and he has not seen his mother as a child, how could he, but he knows that this is his mother but she is not recognisable to him. I can relate to this, I see photographs of my parents as children and as young adults, in the photographs I can see the family resemblance, as a child never understood the claims that I looked like another family member; I thought this was a preposterous claim. But looking through photographs of family members at a similar age, I can now see the sense in the likeness.
The aim of this research is to address memory looking at cultural (family / social) memory. The research has taken several strands and I aim to attempt to put together a family album of memory from the first seven years of my life. This includes people, places and events that I can remember, and record signifiers within locations and recreations – in part I am looking to find out how early memories are recalled and how indexical to the original events infant human memory is? In reality this can never be proven to be fact or denounced as fiction, as memory is held within the mind. Roland Bathes states that photographs can hinder the memory as: “not only is the Photograph never, in essence, a memory...but it actually blocks memory, quickly becomes a counter-memory.” Is the search for accurate memory in relation to the date, the event, the other people present, the location or even the weather possible? Without written evidence of an event happening or a photograph to help prove or disprove an event. In the interviews undertaken this point is often discussed, and while I still aim to undertake the research from a pragmatic stance; can this be achieved?
As Roland Bathes states: “Show your photographs to someone – he will immediately show you his: “Look this is my brother; this is me as a child,” etc.; the Photograph is never anything but an antiphon of “Look,” “See,” “Here it is””. This encompasses much of the groundwork of initial investigations, and goes somewhere to ask the research questions: how accurate and reliable is the human memory in relation to recollection from early years, and how do photographic signifiers help prompt memory. Looking at the collection of photograph I had to start with it was clear that several types of image were evident. The first photograph is proof of our existence, one that using contemporary technology can be beamed around the world via e-mail, SMS or posted on the Internet. In the instance of my first photograph this was a Polaroid, which in reality was shown to a handful of family and friends then not revisited until this series of work was stated. The quality of the material is comparatively crude to its digital successor and up until recently these were not, on the whole, easily replicated. The actuality was that the image had discoloured with a red hue, but by scanning the image and applying simple levels the image was refreshed. I will return to the subject of permanence later.
 |
| Me and Mum: My first Photography June 1976 |
The second type of photograph I observed is the event, a point at which is almost compulsory to take a photograph. The portraits are manufactured, taken with a regimented demeanour; face on with the subject displayed as proud and in the forefront of the image. In reality we do not wander through life chest out, huge wide grin and arms placed as instructed, again remember to smile. Susan Sontag sums up this type of photograph well when she states: “Photographs will offer indisputable evidence that the trip was made, that the program was carried out, that fun was had.”
To investigate the event and memory recollection I undertook the task of recreating several of the images of key events, contacting the sitters and re-enacting the original shot. This has been approached by many photographers such as Daniel Meadows. Meadows revisited the images he shot in the 1970s for his community based Bus project contacting and reshooting twenty-five years after his initial portrait sittings. The other reference was Irina Werning who made carbon copy replacements as part of her Back to the Future Project. I wanted to approach this set of images as a halfway house between the Meadows and Werning images. The idea for this task was to contact the subjects and ask them to pose. I had no real agenda but was in search of the original aura and I wanted to capture the same, or as similar composition – showing not only the physical change of the subjects or physical characteristics, but of the change or similar landscape. Werning produced images that are a perfect recreation and in some ways answer the question about how we have physically changed, but with such tight stringent parameters its does not show how we have changed. In some ways the narrative is very singular and in essence the image could be seen as a singular image, not as a diptych. Meadows images, much as I love them have flaws in that the images are not always shot in the same location and when approaching this task I was mindful that the location was just as important as the subject matter, having said this Meadows was just interested to see the physical change of the subject.
 |
| Me and Jonny Collins going to Emma's Birthday Party 1980 and 2011 |
The image above is my interpretation of the Meadows images. I shot the recreation using a contemporary (1970s) camera the only real interaction that I had with the other person was to discuss the original photograph briefly. This was an intentional move to stop my view having any influence on the shot. This is the first shot taken on a roll of twelve, I actually only wanted to take one image in reaction to the original only being one shot – in reality this would have been a waste of film – part of my rational is that film is a precious commodity to be discussed later; this also stems from an anti-digital stance in that digital allows endless amounts of photographs to be shot and I am still unsure whether or not this cheapens photography.
Flickr has more than: “six billion photos on Flickr at the moment, and to make matters even more incredible, that exact same number of photos are uploaded to Facebook every two months.” This is a colossal amount of images, does the world need this many images and are they of use as a social document. Erik Kessels explored this in his recent work at the Foam Gallery, Amsterdam, in which he printed out every image uploaded to Flickr in a twenty-four hour period allowing the public to submerge themselves in the images: “visualise the feeling of drowning in representations of other people's experiences.” Kessels concludes: “We're exposed to an overload of images nowadays.” The recreations have been undertaken as a simple way of looking at latent memory.
Having undertaken several recreations, contacting and finding the other members of the image I have had varied success. The reasons for varied levels of success have still not be fully concluded and are still under debate; the rational or overview of the measure of success is measured against is not yet fully developed. I do have a personal connection to the images in all instances and it has been in agreement with others to evaluating the success that some images hold an aura while others do not. I can explain why some of the recreations are more successful than others, simply they were the images that were looked upon or stood out, or referred back to throughout my life. Removing a personal sense from the images they do standout for being a strong image, be this the event, the composition, or the style of clothing dating the image. Yes they make the image feel nostalgic and as the intention is to allow the viewer to relate to their own childhood – also reacting to the equipment used.
I have stated in pervious text that I have approached this work with a happy disposition and considered how my childhood was, in reality it was a safe and happy time. While not many photographs exist, and I still dislike having my photograph taken – but in reaction to this research I have forced myself to have my photograph taken, I suspect that most people are self-conscience in front of the camera. For me I want to take photographs and made the decision to be behind the camera and looking back through the photographs that my parents have. I took the photographs, therefore I could not be in the frame.
There are many photographers that I have looked at and dismissed in relation to this research. The initial starting point was to look at photographs that I admire and want to embrace. Nan Goldin and Richard Billingham both produce work that I can take a huge amount of influence from, but not necessarily in a straight forward manner. Both photographers work deal with the family; both are shocking and are in essence the anti-family snap. I reference Goldin’s images due to the way she approaches her subjects with sensitivity and that some images are out of focus or have camera shake, in some instances the images have redeye. Billingham’s initial work of his dysfunctional family in the mid-1990s does not relate to my project apart from the subject of family. The area of Billingham’s work I have referenced is the photographs he shot of his home town in which he photographed places he was familiar with as a child. This is a set of image that are growing and while many of the images are still to be shot. I have a clear understanding of what I want to achieve. The reason for not shooting enough images is that as stated in the text above I remember family events and holidays as warm with blue skies, this does relate to nostalgic memory and as Alan Baddley suggests how we edit our memories, especially at an early age. In popular culture it is often suggested that happy times are warm, television and films use summer weather as a signifier to a happy time, in contrast film noir is dark, cold and is quintessentially miserable. The Guns and Roses Song Sweet Child of Mine refers to a childhood memory in which simple metaphors for the weather are mentioned: “She's got a smile it seems to me, Reminds me of childhood memories, Where everything, Was as fresh as the bright blue sky...”