Tuesday, 31 July 2012

Introduction to Dissertation


The family album: An exploration into the connection between the family photograph, (the event) and memory recollection.

Introduction

As a photographer the main impetus has been technique over subject matter, this research is the continuation from previous work in which the focus was on photographic technologies, and it was through these investigations that the subject of the family album was reached. The methodologies undertaken have lead to a contextual underpinning of the research project.

The original outline of this research was to investigate memory and how photographs are an aide in the recollection of key moments in our past in relation to the images displayed in the family album, addressing questions relating to the photographs we take and how we use and interact with it as a document, further to this was to challenge the indexical nature of the photograph within the context of the family snap. This research is to investigate how we use photographs and how they help to recall memory, no matter how indexical to the event or time as, “these photographs are a window to another time to which we can never return”[1] and as such the memories evoked maybe nostalgic, inaccurate or fictitious. But whether the memory is recalled, lost or indifferent the photograph is indisputable evidence that the event happened. Roland Barthes reaction to his dismay at discovering a photograph in which he did not recognise himself is recorded as, “...and, yet because it was a photograph I could not deny that I had been there (even if I did not know where)”[2], but that “what is no longer, but only and for certain has been.”[3] Barthes statement “that-has-been” was the initial starting point for debate into the connection between the photograph and memory. Susan Sontag reinforces Barthes stating, “a photograph passes for incontrovertible proof that a given thing happened. The picture may distort; but there is always a presumption that something exists, or did exist, which is like what’s in the picture.”[4]

“Cameras go with family life”[5] and “because the family photograph is a ritual of the domestic cult in which the family is both subject and object...” it reinforces “the need for photographs and the need to take photographs”[6]. My family album, the one that my parents collected is not a conventional document, it is however indicative of other family albums I have looked at throughout this investigation in that it is in reality a drawer of random photographs that are on the whole un-catalogued, and it can be argued that the box of photographs is so personal that only we, as a family can decipher the contents. There is the odd piece of evidence, the punctum, scribbled in pencil stating a place, event, subject, date or a time to contextualise the photograph. From the abundance of images deposited in the drawer of family snaps around only thirty images have me in the frame as the subject in my early life[7] which in the age of digital photography could appear to be fairly limited but it could be argued that this would be a fair amount of photographs in relation to the use of film, however the overarching concern is that “not to take pictures of one’s children, particularly when they are small, is a sign of parental indifference.”[8]

This project is in part looking at capturing a glimpse into this time using the archived photographs, as well as memory as a basis for investigations. On starting this work, it became clear that the lack of photographs was not due to the fact that we did not take holiday snaps, but what could be a simple run of bad luck with the handling of the images. This occurrence happened with two sets of holiday snaps, the first was from a holiday in France in 1979 were the images were ruined either by the camera not operating correctly, poor processing or a combination of both. The second was a trip to Spain; the roll of film was deposited at a chemist, then the chemist shut down for several days for a national Spanish holiday, perhaps the film is still waiting to be collected. It is for this reason that we (as a family) have to rely on memories.

In the book Family Snaps, edited by Jo Spence and Patricia Holland; Annette Kuhn suggests that a family snaps should “signalling”, “trace, a clue”, “evoke” and record “historical moments”[9], within the same publication Jeremy Seabrook furthers this theory stating, “essentially, the pictures illustrate a story. They amplify biographies...”[10] The question that this raises is does a family snaps follow the constructs of signalling, trace, and evoke? It is evident viewing the collection of images that the family snap is a vehicle to record loved ones pasted and present, places, an event, a rite of passage, or a milestones, in a manner that documents the way in which we interact with each other. While some of the photographs discussed within this research could initially be seen to be personal to the point of being impenetrable to an outside viewer, they are accessible in that they share the common snapshot in time that as individuals we can relate to.

The work culminated into a road trip in France to recover the unheimlich, testing intuitive memory.

The methodologies undertaken to produce this work included gathering photographs, in some cases re-photographing and scanning information on both sides of the photographs, attempting to recall personal memory and conducting interviews from family and friends. Many of the locations were revisited with family members in an attempt to unlock memory. All subjects who were interviewed for source material are close family and friends.

In an attempt to set the work into clear distinct investigations and to distil the volume of work undertaken following four chapters are to be discussed within this document:

Exhibition and Storage: this is in relation to how we keep and display images.
Expedition and the trophy photograph: proof that we came we saw we concurred.
Faking the p
ast: investigating into the trend for at hipstamatic and instagram, is this the antithesis of creativity or does this process create a false memory or an instantly nostalgic photograph.
The unheimlich: undocumented memory, testing how reliable memory is when challenged with an event that was unrecorded, is it nostalgia and do we need signifiers such as photographs to hold onto the event.

Further evidence of practical investigations and text is available online: http://mattsmithfamilyalbum.blogspot.co.uk/ and in workbook format.


[1] Gregory, J.
[2] Barthes, R.
[3] Barthes, R. 
[4] Sontag, S. 
[5] Sontag, S. 
[6] Bourdieu, P.
[7] Early life in this context refers to the first seven years.
[8] Sontag, S.
[9] Taken from the essay by Annette Kuhn  
[10] Taken from the essay by Jeremy Seabrook 

The unheimlich: undocumented memory

The following is a diary kept to contextualise the  photographs shot on a recent trip to France to find the unheimlich: undocumented memory, testing how reliable memory is when challenged with an event that was unrecorded, is it nostalgia and do we need signifiers such as photographs to hold onto the event
 
Diary
Monday 9th July 2012
It seemed fairly appropriate that the first song that was played on the radio was (Sittin' On) The Dock Of The Bay by Otis Redding, having just travelled on the over night ferry from Portsmouth to Saint-Malo while sat waiting to roll off the ferry. The crossing was very smooth; in fact the sea was choppier in port than out in the channel. Having packed last minute and partly due to the fact that four people and four people’s luggage, including a 5x4 camera, do not fit into a Volkswagen NewBeetle, well it does but can make for an uncomfortable ride.

The ride down from Yorkshire to Portsmouth, Hampshire, was very smooth and with little traffic, which was a pleasing experience after the diversions and warnings on the radio regarding the closure of the A43 past Silverstone. I was more annoyed that I had to listen to the Wimbledon Men’s Singles Final than the British Grand Prix, as Radio 5 ditched the motor racing to cover the warm up to the big final. And because we packed in a hurry with space in mind, we did not have any ablution equipment in the overnight bag and Brittany Ferries are not as plush as North Sea Ferries, so a single sachet of shower gel and a hand towel sufficed for a freshen up in a lukewarm shower. However, breakfast was good, but alas, not to be compared with North Sea Ferries gourmet selection.

The reason for this trip was a two pronged attack, the first was to find the beach road (the location and main point of many discussions), and secondly to take my parents back home to collect a new car as they sold their old one in the UK as it was right hand drive.

The road out of port was the usual fraught arguments, with directions coming from all sides – keep looking for tout-directions and aim for Plancoët and Morlaix. My main obstacle was roundabouts, I can drive on the right, but I get confused when driving anticlockwise around a roundabout, it is just unnatural.

Continuing on from the evening before, I shot some more film on my iPhone of the journey, keeping in mind the work by Tacita Dean, Trying To Find The Spiral Jetty (1997), I have been assured that this quality of footage shot would be good enough. In reality this is the ideal format in that it is what I would imagine most families would use for availability, cost and ease. – after all, as André Bazin stated in Stillness and Time: Photography: “No matter how fuzzy, distorted, or discoloured, no matter how lacking in documentary value the image may be, it shares, by virtue of the very process of its becoming, the being of the model of which it is the reproduction; it is the model.”[1]

The weather was a mixture of some sun and overcast but quite warm, ideal for a road trip. Much as I love Brittany, it does all look the same, all roads go through the centre-ville, which consist of white concrete rendered buildings. Every small village, hamlet or town have the same business establishments; a boulangerie, la poste, de tabac and a bar or restaurant. The biggest observation is that there are never any people in the streets, it make me wonder how businesses stay open, but more pertinently does anyone actually lives there?

It took about two and a half hours from the ferry to reach my parents' house which is situated about twenty minutes inland (east) from Pont-Aven under the hook of Brittany. As we drove over the hills we encountered intermittent reception on the radio, but still managed to hear Paint it Black by the Rolling Stones and Bones by the Killers, so much for French Radio having to play a French language song at least fifty percent of the time.

The afternoon consisted of a trip to the supermarket – traversing though the aisles and aisles of wine, aiming straight for the boulangerie section to sample some baked goods – this is something the French excel at. The smell of supermarkets in France differs from the UK in that they have a certain cold slightly musty smell, but I suppose that this is the freshness of the produce. The crabs and other live produce make me feel uneasy. The French don’t have a word for vegetarian.

The evening ended with a meal at Le Moulin de Rosmadec in Pont-Aven, sitting outside in the sun, to celebrate both my Dad and partner's birthdays. 


Tuesday 10th July 2012
The morning started overcast and it rained a little in the morning. My aim was to find and capture the location I was in search of on a sunny day, but the weather so far this year has not been promising with the jet stream not being in the correct geographical location. Whether this is global warming or a natural cycle is questioned by the media – I remain sceptical. Anyway we set off in search of the beach road the research questions was asking to find, aiming for the coast just west of the E60 (European Route) / N165 (Route nationale) at Guidel, aiming for Larmor-Plage, eventually following the road to Lorient. I still don’t understand why the French have two road numbers; I still think it is to confuse foreign drivers. It is worth pointing out at this point that I did not have any Sat Nav or GPS system and I dare not turn my iPhone on for 3G access as the cost would be extortionate, anyway I did not have a clue where I was going. I also resisted looking on Google Street View. However, I doubt typing in to any locating system, “find a beach I remember form the late 1970s” would be fruitful?

The journey down the E60 / N165 was quiet uneventful, the weather was bright with slight a splattering of rain. Once off the route nationale it was a case of aiming for the coast. The road itself followed the coast closely and we spent some time stopping off to walk through the dunes onto the beach. I have a clear vision of what the beach road looks like. The beach road / car park is at a right-angle off the main road, which follows up a slight incline with space for cars to park at either side. While the landscape today may have looked familiar; it did not resonate memory.


Throughout the day we listen to French radio to try and work out the translation to improve our French and did not hear any recognisable songs on the radio until late in the day, when Dexys Midnight Runners, Come On Eileen and Simple Minds Don’t You Forget About Me were played, along with Echo and the Bunnymen’s The Killing Moon. The French have some strange tastes in music, but will then play some great music in and amongst. I refer back to the fifty percent rule.

Wednesday 11th July 2012
The weather was fine and sunny, but I decided to look along a more northern location, walking around the coast from Port Manech at the end of the D77, aiming for Kercanic using the coastal pathways. From the outset this was clearly not the correct geographical formation, but pretty all the same. The coast was far too rugged and steep.

In the evening we drove to a beach just east of Trévignon on the D1. This was the biggest downpour I have seen for a long time. I did attempt to take some photographs and film, but the driving rain forced filming to stop. The reality was that this was not the beach.

The radio that night was paying Surfin’ Safari by the Beach Boys and A Hard Days Night by The Beatles.

Thursday 12 July 2012

The weather seemed to have brightened up and it was mainly sunshine, ideal for photographing. The aim for today was to search further a field down the E60 / N165 aim for Étel, then Erdeven and finally Quiberon. I had been warned that Quiberon is the Blackpool of Brittany, so not my idea of an ideal Utopia.

The journey was quite a way down the coast from my parents' house in Scaër and took around two hours turning west on the D781 after Hennebont towards Plouhinec on the D170, then the D781 through Erdeven, stopping to explore the megaliths and to buy some bread for lunch at a boulangerie, then following the D768 towards Quiberon along the peninsular.


It was at this point that the Eureuka Moment happened. In the distance I could see the road that I was looking for; a strange feeling ensued. The approach was a twisting road that dipped down to run alongside the Estuary, then up and over a railway crossing. Once the road levelled out I could see a few tracks that led away to the right. The first had trees lining the track; it therefore could not be the correct road. The second was perfect; I had a clear view of the road up towards the horizon and the wide sandy road. The moving image that was recorded documents this very well.

Once out of the car the first impression was that it was extremely windy, but warm. I really didn’t remember the wind when I was there as a child, I am sure I would have remembered this. The reason for mentioning the wind is that once over the sand dunes there were people flying kites and kite surfing – I therefore assume that this is a popular surfers' beach, at the other side of the peninsular the weather is much calmer and the sea is as still as a millpond.

The sun was bright and strong, combined with the ambient sounds and the smell of warm sand and the salty smell of the sea allowed me to reflect upon my visit as a child. Walking through the car park to the beach, the weather-battered and sun-bleached, thin stick and wire fences are still in place winding through the dunes protecting the purple heather beyond.

There was a great deal of accomplishment in finding this beach, but really what was needed was to make sure that this was the correct location. Walking up and down the incline to the dunes and beach was the proof that this was the same place. The difference was that the car park now had a tarmac surface through the middle of the drive and I did not remember the top car park being in existence at all – whether this was here originally, or whether it was not as clear a divide, or it was not important to me as a child could be argued, but I would suspect that not much has really changed.

My preconception was that I would walk up an incline and then hit the paths with the wooden and wire fences through the dunes; my memory dictates that the beach road was wider, but again I deduce that this is due to the fact that I was a small child.

The music played on French Radio was Lilly Allen, a bad cover version of California Dreaming, Dire Straits’ Sultans of Swing, Cure’s Boys Don't Cry, Bob Dylan’s Mr Tambourine Man and the disco classic Le Freak by Chic.

Friday 13th July 2012
If superstition is to be believed then Friday the 13th was perhaps not the best day to be shooting. I am after all shooting on film alongside digital and video, I will not know the outcome of the film until I am back in the UK and I hope it works after all the complaints I have had regarding the transportation of a 5x4 camera and paraphernalia in a small car with four people and their belongings.

The plan of the day was to go back to the beach road on the peninsula at Saint-Pierre-Quiberon just off the D768.

Revising the site has reaffirmed that this is the correct location and I spent a couple of hours photographing and filming, the aim was to produce enough footage of fixed-frame, moving image to put together as a short road trip film.

I decided due to the conditions on a beach that changing 5x4 film was not the best method with sand and salt in the air, deciding instead to stick with eight sheets. This does limit the amount of images that can be taken and due to the limit, I decided not to bracket the exposure, using a digital SLR set at 100ISO to meter with.

Again the results will not be known until I get back to the UK and process the films. I cannot remember being so anxious about film ever. To make sure that I have enough material I have shot on many different formats so that I can distil the work down later. The music listed will, I hope be part of the moving image – although I was disappointed not to hear Plastic Bertrand’s Ca Plane Pour Moi, perhaps this could play over the credits?


[1] Green, D. and Lowery, J. (2006)