The following text is the proposal for the final submission of work - it is very quote heavy and I have realised that sometimes I can read far more than I should. The final dissertation (based on the final body of work) is between twenty and twenty-five thousand words. Perhaps this should contain the same amount of citations spread out ?
My initial
concerns in this research project was to produce a set of images that captured
the essence of my childhood, adamant that I wanted to remain true to the
indexical nature of the original images, and the memory. Dissecting the
question, the main issue posed is; is a record of family history a history or
simply an edited reality?
Through
investigations the question has become more defined. The family album is
obviously an edited reality, identified through the seminal work of artists, Jo
Spence and Rosy Martin but what exactly is the history that they / we construct
through them?
The images are
signifiers to a past but how do they operate to construct that past and how
does the changing context in which we view these images contribute to that
construction
“However,
memory is never just a straightforward process of recording lest we forget and,
even in the best equipped of minds, it can be a slippery mechanism. It can be
both elusive and intrusive and we can rarely be completely sure of its fidelity
to the events or facts that it recalls.”
As this quote
suggests the event is recorded as a general overview; the intricacies of the
details are forgotten. When attempting to recall memory or by interviewing
other family members and friends who were present at the event I have observed
that memory cannot be defined as fact as different family members recalled events
differently, or pickup on other details. In most cases, a general overview of
the memory of the event or trip could be recalled, but detail or defined
information about individual events differed; if the memory was recalled.
Roland Barthes deals with just this issue when discussing a photograph
of his mother as a child stated that: “that-has-been
and is no more”
in which he declares indisputable evidence that an event happened and cannot be
revisited, Barthes continues to seek proof of the event by stating that the:
“...real thing which has been placed before the lens, without which there would
be no photograph”, whereas: “Painting can feign reality without having seen
it.”
But without indisputable evidence did
the event happen, or is the memory of an event or place fictitious, as
Barthes continues: “What is no longer, but only and for certain has been”.
Barthes continues to explain his dismay at discovering a photograph in which he
did not recognise himself: “And, yet because it was a photograph I could not
deny that I had been there.”
If this is the case then the
photograph is replacing the event, or pointing towards a memory, how indexical
is that memory. In some cases looking through the images I have, taken in the
1970s, the photographs are the memory. I was clearly too young to remember the
event, but signifiers in the image allow me to enter a past memory, regardless
of how indexical to the event the memory is. In reality I was creating a memory
based on given information from others, whereas approaching this subject as an
adult I am able to make choices with a clearer rationalised outcome, allowing
me to explore with an informed decision to collect signifiers, these signifiers
may not allow me to step back in time, they will however allow me to see and
experience the places I saw as a child.
The intrinsic value of a photograph means that the image
is always in the past, where as a moving image is in the present. With a moving
film the narrative is paramount to the device; the viewer is observing an event
that is taking place, whereas with a photograph the event has taken place,
therefore photographs promote nostalgia, to return to a time that is no longer
as time is irreversible, “and nostalgia becomes the reaction to that sad fact.”
Barthes states that “”Like real world, the filmic world is sustained by the
presumption that, as Husserl says, “the experience will constantly continue to
flow by in the same constitutive style””
but that a photograph: “is without future”
and that the photograph holds: “no protensity, whereas the cinema is protensive”
Barthes assigns the term ‘that has been’
to the still photograph, whereas the moving image holds the viewer and takes
the viewer on a journey, not allowing the viewer to absorb and read the image,
instead we are part of the film not an observer.
This raises the question of whether the photograph is
always nostalgic? Susan Sontag stated that the influence of photography on
society has created: “a nostalgic time right now, and photographs actively
promote nostalgia. Photography is an elegiac art, a twilight art. Most subjects
photographed are, just by virtue of being photographed, touched with pathos.”
Jeremy Seabrook states: “Essentially, the pictures illustrate a story. They
amplify biographies...”
photographs do not necessarily communicate the truth and could be used to
optimise the narrative; after all we want to be remembered in a positive and
triumphant light. If the events in my past are not necessarily indexical to the
event they are seen as nostalgic. The dictionary definition of nostalgia is: “a
wistful desire to return in thought or in fact to a former time in one's
life...”
Or as Fredric Jameson suggests the: "celebrations of the imaginary style
of a real past" which he sees as "something of a substitute for that
older system of historical representation, indeed as a virtual
symptom-formation, a formal compensation for the enfeeblement of historicity in
our own time."
In essence photographs are nostalgic, they are a window to the past allowing
the viewer to look at another time, the photograph has frozen a moment, held a
signifier to unlock a memory.
It can be argued that in this project I am attempting to
return to a happier time, to memorialise the past, as Linda Hutcheon describes
it to: “look and linger longingly”
which was happy however in reality I am looking at tracing the footsteps of
what has made me. Hutcheon describes the excess of nostalgia today as due to: “...technology...
audio and video reproduction, nostalgia no longer has to rely on individual
memory or desire: it can be fed forever by quick access to an infinitely
recyclable past.” This can be seen through genealogy websites such as
ancestry.co.uk, or image storage sites such as Flickr and Photobucket, along
with video storage sites such as YouTube. All the mentioned sites allow the
viewer to explore the past with indisputable evidence, although there is still
a large portion that still relies on imagination, after all the material is
uploaded after has been edited. Google+ and Facebook have resource that allow
the user to create a timeline that can be added to, in some cases the metadata
is stored automatically and the events or uploads have to be edited or deleted
to remove devices, rather than adding content individually. Unfortunately this
kind of resource was not available in my formative years, but as Andreas
Huyssen states, this can create conflict: "The more memory we store on
data banks, the more the past is sucked into the orbit of the present, ready to
be called up on the screen".
A statement made in 1985 by David
Lowenthal has become more profound in the twenty-first century: "formerly
confined in time and place, nostalgia today engulfs the whole past",
as mass culture use a variety resources to capture the past, if unconsciously,
nostalgic.
The research has
highlighted that the events undertaken during family excursions or celebrations
have many different viewpoints and in many cases the information regarding
activity or location is often complex: "history, memory, and language
intersect so precisely as to be almost indistinguishable" (Brink). But further to this the event
becomes indistinguishable, as memory is either fragmented or lost without the
use of a signifier to a memory such as written text or a visual aide such as a
photograph. The storage of memory is filtered, especially at an early age. Alan
Baddeley suggests that children under the age of three years have: “…infantile
amnesia” that “is a well-established phenomenon, its interpretation remains
controversial. One explanation claims that crucial aspects of the brain have
not yet developed, making infants essentially like amnesic patients
(Moscovitch, 1985)”. It is that amnesia as a child that makes
us struggle to contextualise the facts, but once the brain is fully developed
there is still a negotiation between memory and reality, as we forget events,
or look at them from a biased viewpoint and need a trigger to spark the memory,
how indexical it is to the original event, but with the development in social
media such as Facebooks’ timeline, which allows the user to plot
events, places visited and key dates to be entered along a timeline this will
help to give context. It could be argued that his further step in technology that
are used to plot the past and making links between events, producing a sleek
timeline is making memory clinical and not allowing the holder of the memory to
explore their individual past. Yes, the help of signifiers does allow memory to
be recalled but is the memory the event that happened, or the film? The
material that is used to promote the Google Chrome
resource is nostalgic, the narrative is about generations of family being able
to leave messages for loved ones or the passing of time. The overarching theme
of the advertisements is melancholic
in that a whole lifetime passes within one minute therefore we need to collect
and savour memory. This could create a bank of text, imagery and film that no
longer requires the view to use memory recollection as all the information
presented is all that is needed for the memory to exist.
Andreas Huyssen
discusses indexicality as: “the old dichotomy between history and fiction”, whereas Henri Bergson defined memory as:
“the intersection of mind and matter”, resulting in the blurring of fact and
fiction into an unaccountable history. Michael Haldrup and
Jonas
Larsen suggest that: “It is in the space of the photograph that we can still enjoy
longed-for familial happiness”
the photograph therefore triggers a sentimental emotion and we associate the
past with a joyous time, leading back to the notion of nostalgia.
Joan Gibbons discusses the recollection of a family event
in terms of: “Cognitive memory... “The
way that memory is valued, then, has shifted enormously from the idea of it
being a storehouse of data which, given the right technique, is recoverable in
an ordered manner to the notion that it is key to our emotional understanding
of ourselves and the world.” Marcel Proust discussed: “voluntary and
involuntary memory” declaring that voluntary memory is
accumulated from everyday encounters that cue memory, whereas the voluntary is
to make a deliberate focused effort to recall the past and a photograph is a
tool that can be used in this phenomenon.
In relation to individual memory, François-Xavier Lavenne,
Virginie Renard and François Tollet state that: “a subjective experience and
memories belong to the individual, helping to build identity by differentiating
this individual from others.”
Whereas the collective memory is in the case of this research the memory of all
who attended the event. This has been evident in a series of postcards sent
from location visited, the device is used to document and state any memory,
either as a long standing memory, or as a refreshed memory the collective memory is the place visited,
but the individual memory is the activities undertaken. Through interviews
memory has been conflicted regarding detail of the event undertaken.
Francis Yates discusses the notion of automatic memory
suggesting: “The development of the
‘artificial memory’ was highly dependant on techniques of visualisation, such
as the location of a piece of knowledge in an imagined, clearly defined locus
(often building) or the attachment of data or ideas to striking (and therefore
more memorable) images.” When venturing to a recognisable
place we assume that certain elements will exist, an example would be a visit
to a British seaside resort. We are bombarded with images that invoke senses that
are synonymous with the seaside, such as the sea, sand, ice-cream parlours and
vendors, amusement arcades, postcards and the promenade: “...each single image
contains triggers to the ‘density and flavour of life’, which through
accumulation, emulates memory’s ‘endless flow of connections’.”
These iconic, ambiguous, familiar signifiers appear at most seaside resorts, in
different guises; therefore we assume that we are familiar with that landscape
even if we have not visited the location. Another factor that is to be taken
into account is the use of photographs and other visual media giving an
experience of the location; automatic memory. The natural is related to the
detail of a certain ice-cream seller or the strata of a rock formation on the
beach, but this could come from a secondary source such as a photograph or moving
image. Overall the images produced as part of this research must hold the
following values suggested by Annette Kuhn, to “signalling” to “trace, a clue”
to “evoke”, to recall “historical moments”.
The body of work within the research that will unpackage this concern will be
to revisit a location, visited as a child and look for traces and the punctum
of memory. This will be undertaken using a list from memory, then to photograph
the location and reflect upon the photographs taken. Postcards are also to be
produced as a journal to collect evidence, this will include memories venue
that are still present or have changed, or places that no longer exist. There
will also be opportunity to observe and record how a in memory distorts the
original event, this is in relation to how memory is stored and how we remember
situations and places.
From the work
undertaken within this project I suggest that the research is, a posthumous
status of memento mori, a statement that should normally be in conjunction with
the notion of death, but as Joy Gregory states when discussing her photographic
work: “...photographs are a window to another time to which we can never
return”, as time is unable to be revisited,
therefore is in essence deceased. Susan Sontag suggests: "All
photographs are memento mori. To take a photograph is to participate in another
person’s (or thing’s) mortality, vulnerability, mutability. Precisely by slicing
out this moment and freezing it, all photographs testify to time’s relentless
melt.”
The viewer of the images produced must be able to
identify with the work on an individual level, going beyond the simple snaps
shot as Annette Kuhn suggests that: “...memories evoked by a photo do not
simply spring out of the image itself, but are generated in an intertext of
discourses between past and present...”
The aim for the
final body of images is to create photographs exploring several different
themes producing a varied body of work that investigates the geographical
location I used to visit as a child, looking for the changes in architecture
and business establishments, the landscape or physical changes of myself. The
work will test individual memory and look at how we use images as signifiers to
recall memory and the way in which Photographs construct memories. The majority
of the final body of work will be based on a two week period, the rationale for
this is that a family holiday usually last for a fortnight. While this could be
seen as an overambitious goal the reality is that it will concentrate the work
and contextualise the research, by limiting the time at which we undertake a
family holiday this will reflect the use of film and limiting the frames to
twenty-four or thirty-six. The two week period will take place in June of 2012,
this is for two reasons. The first is that this will allow the process and any
post production work to be undertaken on the images before final conclusions
are drawn for the final dissertation, and secondly my observation of my family
holidays is that they were taken during the summer, usually just after school
broke for the summer holidays.
During this
period the tasks undertaken will include:
Looking further
than the photograph – looking at signifiers that exist within the frame of the
original photographs, this is to test the theory that the photograph is the
memory, not the actual event, investigating deeper into the evidence of the
image and looking at what the signifiers are within the image, can they help to
recall memory?
Visiting and
photographing landscapes of places that were visited on excursions, focusing on
places using individual memory and photographing them as they exist now. I will
endeavour to photograph the images without including any signifiers to the
present day and using techniques to try and steer the viewer to see the images
as contemporary to the late 1970s or early 1980s, this is to attempt to trick
the viewer into believing the photograph is contemporary to the period, evoking
nostalgia. This task is in reaction to the work by Richard Billingham who shot
photographs in relation to places he would visit as a child. These images will
be shot on a format contemporary to the late 1970s and early 1980s. In the
project From Back Home (2001–2008) undertaken by Anders Petersen and JH
Engström the: “photographers travelled into the heart of their subject, their
potent and captivating photographs becoming an intense voyage of discovery into
both the place and people that shaped them, and their relationship with one
another.”
Postcards were
part of a family holiday and I still send postcards back home, they capture the
event and hold a narrative to the event that was taking place. An e-mail or
weblog does not hold the same intrinsic value. A postcard is more personal than
an electronic message as the tangible quality of the personally written note
along with the photograph combine together, held on a piece of paper that has
been at and is part of the event. The postcards that have already sent recall
the memory of what happened originally and what was found. The new set of
postcards will simply describe what was found and what memories have been
recalled, then posted back home.
As part of the
practical tasks undertake I started to look at psychogeography and asking
others to produce a set of images of a place that they remember visiting. While
this is not fully in line with the conventions of psychogeography it does
embrace the notion of asking others to produce work that can be compared. The
motivation for this was to investigate what signifiers to the past they found,
this is to be undertaken without any interaction from myself after briefing.
This is in reaction to notion of individual and collective memory.
Outside of the
two week time period I will be investigations into the following:
Investigating
into re-enactments, this is with reference to Daniel Meadows and Irina
Werning’s work by undertook the task of recreating several of the
images of key events, contacting the sitters and re-enacting the original shot.
Meadows revisited the images he shot in the 1970s for his community based Bus
project contacting and reshooting twenty-five years after his initial portrait
sittings. This
is in comparison to Irina Werning who made carbon copy replacements as part of
her Back to the Future Project. The
manner in which I am approaching this is to note the physical differences
between the two images and to interview the other participants to allow them to
recall memory in relation to the photograph and the event. I am approaching this
set of images as a re-enactment that is not choreographed and allowing the
other participants to conduct their pose as they feel is applicable. In reality
this is a short piece of work as there are only a limited number of image I have from the 1970s.
An issue that has
been raised during the archiving aspect of the project is the permanence of the
photographic image. Some of the images from the late 1970s have been damaged
but not necessarily due to the storage, but the chemical makeup of the image.
The images themselves have been repaired very quickly using computer software,
restoring them to the original, if not better than original state. I have
conducted experiments, exploring the physical change of an image due to the
being exposed to sunlight. This consisted of producing a single roll of film,
cutting into two parts, scanning and storing one part and exposing the other
end to sunlight to see the physical change. This task is an investigation in to
how the photograph reacts to light and to test if the negative can be
manipulated into producing a faded image and to test if a nostalgic image can
be falsely created, this will be compared to the selection of iPhone
Applications that use a range of filters to create a faded and discoloured
effect.
The final part
of the project is to investigate how we use and exhibit family snaps. At
the end of life, at a funeral or remembrance a photograph is often used as the
signifier to allow the individual or congregation to remember the absent
person, as Susan Sontag suggests: “Today everything exists to end in a
photograph.”
The work has
been shot predominately on 35mm as a reaction to the amateur photographer (the family
snap). The overarching aim for the work is to produce a body of work that
reflects the family album and the snapshot; I have explored different methods
of how images are produced with varying success. I want to produce images on
both digital and film. A photograph taken on holiday in the late 1970s images
would be shot on film, as the technology of the time would dictate twenty-four
or thirty-six images and the cost of each frame was incurred whether or not the
shot was successful. This limits the number of images to be taken, working in
the contemporary style of the late 1970s, whereas the amount of photographs a
digital camera are endless and can be deleted or reshot if unsatisfactory. In
some instances the images will be shot on digital due to the experimental
nature of that set of images, as some postproduction work is needed to build
the images.
The images are
to be displayed in several formats including prints and an online presence. In
the tradition of holiday snaps I intend to produce the prints from a high
street chemist at postcard size 6” x 4” alongside an online storage resource.
The rationale for using both online and printed artefacts is taken from the
interviews taken individuals in relation to the presentation of family snaps.
Jo Spence and Patricia Holland
Facebook.com: timeline released on
18th April 2012. This allows the user to plot events, places visited
and key dates to be entered along a timeline.
Google
Chrome: Dear Sophie
Michael Haldrup and Jonas Larsen
François-Xavier Lavenne, Virginie Renard, François Tollet
Spence, J. and Holland, P.
Spence, J. and Holland, P.
Anders Petersen and JH Engström
Daniel Meadows: The Bus was
included as part of the Ways of Looking festival